_____________________
                                                                               |                     
                                                          _____________________|_____________________
                                                         |                                           
                             ____________________________|
                            |                            |
                            |                            |                      _____________________
                            |                            |                     |                     
                            |                            |_____________________|_____________________
                            |                                                                        
 _? CALDWELL _______________|
|                           |
|                           |                                                   _____________________
|                           |                                                  |                     
|                           |                             _____________________|_____________________
|                           |                            |                                           
|                           |____________________________|
|                                                        |
|                                                        |                      _____________________
|                                                        |                     |                     
|                                                        |_____________________|_____________________
|                                                                                                    
|
|--Susan E. CALDWELL 
|  (1861 - 1871)
|                                                                               _Zachariah BUTLER ___+
|                                                                              | (1736 - 1792)       
|                                                         _James BUTLER _______|_Sarah (Sally) BOWE _
|                                                        | (1758 - 1841)         (.... - 1770)       
|                            _James (Walk) BUTLER _______|
|                           | (1800 - 1875) m 1823       |
|                           |                            |                      _____________________
|                           |                            |                     |                     
|                           |                            |_Sally ? ____________|_____________________
|                           |                                                                        
|_Permelia Caroline BUTLER _|
  (1835 - 1913)             |
                            |                                                   _____________________
                            |                                                  |                     
                            |                             _William HANSARD ____|_____________________
                            |                            |                                           
                            |_Elizabeth Frances HANSARD _|
                              (1803 - 1882) m 1823       |
                                                         |                      _____________________
                                                         |                     |                     
                                                         |_Jennett FANNIN _____|_____________________