_Zachariah BUTLER ___+
                                                                  | (1736 - 1792)       
                                             _James BUTLER _______|_Sarah (Sally) BOWE _
                                            | (1758 - 1841)         (.... - 1770)       
                       _Zachariah BUTLER ___|
                      | (1782 - 1822)       |
                      |                     |                      _____________________
                      |                     |                     |                     
                      |                     |_Sally ? ____________|_____________________
                      |                                                                 
 _Thomas S. BUTLER ___|
| (1805 - 1865) m 1826|
|                     |                                            _____________________
|                     |                                           |                     
|                     |                      _Thomas B. BULLARD __|_____________________
|                     |                     |                                           
|                     |_Nancy BULLARD ______|
|                       (.... - 1822)       |
|                                           |                      _____________________
|                                           |                     |                     
|                                           |_Ann MOSELEY ________|_____________________
|                                                                                       
|
|--Ann BUTLER 
|  (1841 - ....)
|                                                                  _____________________
|                                                                 |                     
|                                            _____________________|_____________________
|                                           |                                           
|                      _Charlie PAYNE ______|
|                     |                     |
|                     |                     |                      _____________________
|                     |                     |                     |                     
|                     |                     |_____________________|_____________________
|                     |                                                                 
|_Julia PAYNE ________|
  (1804 - 1869) m 1826|
                      |                                            _____________________
                      |                                           |                     
                      |                      _____________________|_____________________
                      |                     |                                           
                      |_Rhoda CAWTHON ______|
                                            |
                                            |                      _____________________
                                            |                     |                     
                                            |_____________________|_____________________