_James BUTLER _______+
                                                                           | (1758 - 1841)       
                                             _Christopher Columbus BUTLER _|_Sally ? ____________
                                            | (1786 - 1850) m 1809                               
                       _James M. BUTLER ____|
                      | (1813 - 1891)       |
                      |                     |                               _____________________
                      |                     |                              |                     
                      |                     |_Mahala COLE _________________|_____________________
                      |                       (1792 - 1860) m 1809                               
 _John Wesley BUTLER _|
| (1840 - 1916) m 1860|
|                     |                                                     _____________________
|                     |                                                    |                     
|                     |                      _James Peter CRAWFORD ________|_____________________
|                     |                     | (1770 - ....)                                      
|                     |_Sarah CRAWFORD _____|
|                       (1815 - 1852)       |
|                                           |                               _____________________
|                                           |                              |                     
|                                           |_Elizabeth ? _________________|_____________________
|                                                                                                
|
|--Emory A. BUTLER 
|  (1870 - ....)
|                                                                           _____________________
|                                                                          |                     
|                                            ______________________________|_____________________
|                                           |                                                    
|                      _William J. DUKE ____|
|                     | (1811 - 1880) m 1840|
|                     |                     |                               _____________________
|                     |                     |                              |                     
|                     |                     |______________________________|_____________________
|                     |                                                                          
|_Nancie Ann DUKE ____|
  (1843 - 1905) m 1860|
                      |                                                     _____________________
                      |                                                    |                     
                      |                      ______________________________|_____________________
                      |                     |                                                    
                      |_Delila A. E. DUKE __|
                        (1812 - ....) m 1840|
                                            |                               _____________________
                                            |                              |                     
                                            |______________________________|_____________________