_____________________
                                                                           |                     
                                             ______________________________|_____________________
                                            |                                                    
                       _____________________|
                      |                     |
                      |                     |                               _____________________
                      |                     |                              |                     
                      |                     |______________________________|_____________________
                      |                                                                          
 _Joe CLIFTON ________|
|                     |
|                     |                                                     _____________________
|                     |                                                    |                     
|                     |                      ______________________________|_____________________
|                     |                     |                                                    
|                     |_____________________|
|                                           |
|                                           |                               _____________________
|                                           |                              |                     
|                                           |______________________________|_____________________
|                                                                                                
|
|--Florence CLIFTON 
|  
|                                                                           _James BUTLER _______+
|                                                                          | (1758 - 1841)       
|                                            _Christopher Columbus BUTLER _|_Sally ? ____________
|                                           | (1786 - 1850) m 1809                               
|                      _Joseph Joel BUTLER _|
|                     | (1812 - 1881) m 1836|
|                     |                     |                               _____________________
|                     |                     |                              |                     
|                     |                     |_Mahala COLE _________________|_____________________
|                     |                       (1792 - 1860) m 1809                               
|_Elizabeth BUTLER ___|
  (1844 - ....)       |
                      |                                                     _____________________
                      |                                                    |                     
                      |                      ______________________________|_____________________
                      |                     |                                                    
                      |_Catherine M. SHAW __|
                        (1818 - 1905) m 1836|
                                            |                               _____________________
                                            |                              |                     
                                            |______________________________|_____________________