_Christopher Columbus BUTLER _+
                                                                       | (1786 - 1850) m 1809         
                                                  _James M. BUTLER ____|_Mahala COLE _________________
                                                 | (1813 - 1891)         (1792 - 1860)                
                       _James Madison BUTLER ____|
                      | (1846 - 1907) m 1867     |
                      |                          |                      _James Peter CRAWFORD ________
                      |                          |                     | (1770 - ....)                
                      |                          |_Sarah CRAWFORD _____|_Elizabeth ? _________________
                      |                            (1815 - 1852)                                      
 _Crawford C. BUTLER _|
| (1876 - 1913) m 1903|
|                     |                                                 _Thomas HANDLEY ______________+
|                     |                                                | (1790 - 1852)                
|                     |                           _George HANDLEY _____|______________________________
|                     |                          | (1819 - 1891) m 1838                               
|                     |_Sarah Elizabeth HANDLEY _|
|                       (1840 - 1907) m 1867     |
|                                                |                      _James EARNEST _______________
|                                                |                     | (1780 - ....)                
|                                                |_Mary EARNEST _______|_Mary Ann CURL _______________
|                                                  (1820 - ....) m 1838  (1791 - ....)                
|
|--Clyde BUTLER 
|  (1908 - ....)
|                                                                       ______________________________
|                                                                      |                              
|                                                 _____________________|______________________________
|                                                |                                                    
|                      __________________________|
|                     |                          |
|                     |                          |                      ______________________________
|                     |                          |                     |                              
|                     |                          |_____________________|______________________________
|                     |                                                                               
|_Melissa PREUTT _____|
  (1885 - 1945) m 1903|
                      |                                                 ______________________________
                      |                                                |                              
                      |                           _____________________|______________________________
                      |                          |                                                    
                      |__________________________|
                                                 |
                                                 |                      ______________________________
                                                 |                     |                              
                                                 |_____________________|______________________________