_Christopher Columbus BUTLER _+
                                                                        | (1786 - 1850) m 1809         
                                                 _Patrick Henry BUTLER _|_Mahala COLE _________________
                                                | (1826 - 1908) m 1850    (1792 - 1860)                
                         _James Russell BUTLER _|
                        | (1869 - 1943) m 1890  |
                        |                       |                        _Thomas DANIELS ______________
                        |                       |                       |                              
                        |                       |_Agnes Terry DANIEL ___|______________________________
                        |                         (1828 - 1903) m 1850                                 
 _Patrick Henry BUTLER _|
| (1896 - 1970) m 1918  |
|                       |                                                _James L. SMITH ______________
|                       |                                               | (1804 - ....)                
|                       |                        _John Andrew SMITH ____|_Debora ? ____________________
|                       |                       | (1845 - 1900) m 1863    (1807 - ....)                
|                       |_Sarah Jane SMITH _____|
|                         (1871 - 1943) m 1890  |
|                                               |                        _? LINDSEY ___________________
|                                               |                       | (.... - 1850)                
|                                               |_Hariet P. LINDSEY ____|_Mary Ann ? __________________
|                                                 (1843 - 1911) m 1863    (1811 - ....)                
|
|--Robert L. BUTLER 
|  
|                                                                        ______________________________
|                                                                       |                              
|                                                _______________________|______________________________
|                                               |                                                      
|                        _? EZELL ______________|
|                       | (.... - 1898)         |
|                       |                       |                        ______________________________
|                       |                       |                       |                              
|                       |                       |_______________________|______________________________
|                       |                                                                              
|_Jessie N. EZELL ______|
  (1897 - ....) m 1918  |
                        |                                                ______________________________
                        |                                               |                              
                        |                        _______________________|______________________________
                        |                       |                                                      
                        |_Anna R. ? ____________|
                          (1874 - 1924)         |
                                                |                        ______________________________
                                                |                       |                              
                                                |_______________________|______________________________