| | Hannah E. Williams 1840–1861 | | |
| | Sarah Elizabeth Handley 1841–1907 James Madison Butler 1846–1907 | | |
| | William Payton Handley 1843–1925 Mary Josephine Butler 1857–1942 Mary Susan Wallace 1856–1876 Mary Elizabeth Wallace 1839–1874 | | |
| | Marion Newton Handley 1853–1941 Frances T. Butler 1854–1944 Nancy Mahala Butler 1856–1893 | | |
Lucretia Caroline Handley 1863–… | | |
| | | | |