| | William Livingston Butler 1854–1929 Rebecca J. Butler 1854–1908 Dovie L. Skinner 1884–1967 | | | | Russel Benjamin Butler 1822–1901 Christina Mary Daniels 1823–1852 Martha Ellen Hardy 1825–1914 | | | | Christopher Columbus Butler 1786–1860 | | |
| | | | Ziba (Geba) (Zebra) Hardy …–… |
|
|
| | | Milton P. Butler 1809–1871 | | | | Christopher Columbus Butler 1786–1860 | | |
| |
|
|
|